the trading post

PCB Blog

Import Into Canada
Fundamentals
Frequently Asked Questions
Import Duty
Tax
Shipping
Freight Management
ACI eManifest
20
Nov
'
26

Confused by Reclassification? Here’s Why You Need a Product Review

Let’s imagine a situation. You are an importer, and you have worked with your broker for many years. When you signed on with your broker, you underwent a process known as ‘product review’ with the goal of classifying your existing goods. They needed to know what you’re importing, and because this is your first time importing the product or this is your first time working with them as a broker, it made sense. You give them the information, the documentation, and everything else that they might need to reasonably make a database of your imports. You are satisfied with what you provide, they advise that it looks good on their end, and you rest easy knowing that at least that’s done. 

Then, about two years later, your broker tells you that you should really get another product review for your goods once again, essentially reclassifying the items in the database of goods they built for you. You’re confused and, to be honest, a little annoyed. Surely, if there was some regulatory change, you’d have heard about it from your broker first. If there were some new sweeping rule that affected your goods, you’d know. Why do you have to check everything all over again? What’s worse, they’re suggesting that this is a thing you should do every two years at a minimum! You are confused. What is going on?

As brokers, we are often posed with questions about the concept of ‘classification’ and ‘reclassification.’ The idea of a product review makes a lot of sense in the early days, but is often neglected as a responsibility in the years that follow. In this week’s blog, we’ll break down the concept of classification and why an importer benefits greatly from doing it regularly. 

Why Does Classification Matter?

The short answer is that you're legally obligated to classify your goods accurately before importing them, so it matters a great deal. Even a small error can have a force multiplier of financial consequences, and under the US Customs Modernization Act, importers are legally obligated to accurately classify their goods as part of ‘reasonable care.’ It is a significant and perilously important part of the process that is not to be taken lightly. 

A discovery of negligent misclassification can cost a significant amount in penalties, and if you think it won’t happen to you, you should know that the Department of Justice earlier this year stated the Trade Fraud Task Force (TFTF) surpassed $1 billion in criminal and civil recoveries, penalties, forfeitures, and charged losses just one year since its launch, and its eyes are almost entirely focused on Customs-related fraud. Not only are penalty amounts for this kind of infraction going up as a result of a recent executive order, but the best case you can hope for through mitigation is 50% of that penalty. You can very easily get a penalty for not paying attention as much as taking an illegal act on purpose. 

One of the best examples of a company being punished for misclassification came in 2024 when Customs discovered that a company had placed what they described as ‘sham’ passenger seats in a shipment of transit vans. In their eyes, the company was attempting to earn the classification of ‘passenger vehicle,’ as the duty rate of passenger vehicles was 2.5% while the duty rate for cargo vehicles sat at a hefty 25%. To Customs, it was clear what was going on. 

Unsurprisingly, the courts agreed, and they ultimately were made to pay $365 million in restitution. While it is beyond the purview of this blog to speak to this company’s intentions, this very easily could have been an error or any number of other things, the point in bringing it up is that Customs takes this tremendously seriously, and they are not concerned with the ‘why’ of a misclassification. 

Classification is the backbone of your declaration and a profound legal obligation. The problem, and why your broker is now suggesting a biannual product review, is that you may not know your classification as well as you think, and the consequences of that mistake can be dire. 

Why Should I Get a Product Review?

The answer is, ultimately, twofold. First, there’s a reason to believe that since the last time you checked, things could have changed in terms of regulation, and second, things may have changed on the home front. Add in that right now is a moment in history when it has never paid off more to be by the book and compliant, and you have a compelling case for a regular look through. 

Reason 1: Things Can Change 

To understand why reclassifying your goods through a product review is so important, you need to understand what the Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (HTSUS) is. Put simply, it is a list of every good on earth built on the WCO’s international Harmonized System. Each item gets a universal six-digit code that is then suffixed by additional numbers unique to the country you are importing from. For example, the US has eight- and 10-digit codes to help determine a good’s classification and, thus, its duty rate in the US. 

This document is incredibly detailed and comprehensive, but it is not the easiest to interpret, and it is not totally infallible. Its ‘living document’ nature can, for importers, often feel like the goalposts are shifting. Once a year, the HTS is updated. Not all the codes change every year, but there can be significant changes to specific chapters. While it might only seem like two digits are changing with that chapter, those two digits can fundamentally change everything about that classification. Add to that changes that are made as new tariff orders are issued, and you could be looking at an order that adds a new number or potentially even a list of new numbers. It is a fluctuating document that changes regularly. 

The source of these updates can come from a host of places, including the United States International Trade Commission (USITC), CBP, legislation, or through trade courts ruling on disputes, and the issuing changes can absolutely affect your goods, even without you knowing if you aren’t paying attention. If you aren’t watching the news, or rendered the services of a skilled Trade Advisor, you can very easily be caught unawares by the changes made in this document, and that is the worst place to be as an importer.

Notably, a change in the HTS doesn’t just affect things like tariffs or free trade qualification, but dictates what Partner Government Agencies (PGAs) are involved in the shipment. What this means is that if your classification is wrong, you could find yourself in hot water not just with CBP but with a relevant PGA as well, which is a complication that you do not want. Many products that are regulated by a PGA have a liability of three times the value of the shipment.

A great example of what kind of discourse the HTSUS houses, and the pitfalls that await in the world of classification is this: In 2003, a company argued in court that their action figures should be considered toys as opposed to dolls. A doll, at this point in time, had a tariff rate of 12%, while toys were only 6.8%. The company’s argument was that the figures depicted non-humans and, as such, should be classified as toys. The judge agreed that the action figures were not human, and the company was reimbursed for the duties they overpaid, and the changes were made in the HTSUS. 

With that in mind, it’s not just external changes to the HTS codes, but a change on the manufacturing side of things can demand a new classification as well. Alterations to component parts can change a good's classification, so regularly updating and confirming your classification is imperative, even if your goods are stable in the news cycle. 

As you can see, it’s a complicated affair that requires a level of in-depth, industry understanding that can border on the indecipherable for a regular person. Which is why, in most cases, you need to trust your customs broker to be the one to keep you abreast of changes related to your goods. They have the expertise and are the ones who will be the first to receive new regulatory information as it is released. That is why it is so important that businesses engage the services of a trusted, qualified, compliance-first broker with their finger on the pulse and a communication plan in place. 

Reason 2: Your Broker is Not In Your Boardroom

The second reason why a regular product review is vital to the continued success of an importer is that you could be making changes to your imports that affect that good’s classification without being fully aware of what you are affecting. Changing a screw manufacturer for your rocking chairs can fundamentally change its classification as a product, as well as its country of origin and free trade agreement access, and that change could have a knock-on effect because classification dictates all kinds of things, including which tariffs apply to it and which free trade agreements it can qualify for. 

Determining what goods are affected by a trade measure like a tariff depends, in every case, on their classification, and the divisions and subdivisions within that classification determine where the line is actually drawn. Even minute changes made at the manufacturing level can put your goods in a profoundly precarious place. While it might seem like nothing, this is not the moment in history to say ‘close enough,’ as the surge of new tariffs and the steady rise of Customs enforcement over the past few years have made accuracy and compliance costly pain points if ignored.

The reality is that your broker is not there when you make every decision for your goods, and what is important to ‘trade compliance’ may not even break the surface when you are making those kinds of changes to your product or policy, and that is why it is a good standard practice to twice a year get a product review to make sure your goods are still where you left them the last time you classified. 

If goods, components, and processing of the goods aren't changing, the industry best practice is to at the very least get a full reclassification biannually (every two years). It should be considered a vital part of the importing process and a regular part of any international business’s standard operating procedures, and of particular importance when onboarding a new supplier or when a product’s bill of materials changes.

Why Should You Trust a Classification Expert with Your Next Import?

The product review and classification of your goods can be deceptive. It is, on the surface, the declaration that feels the most ‘Google-able’. However, as we’ve discussed above, it is not to be trifled with, and diligence is a mandatory part of importing.

Accuracy has always been remarkably important and a legal requirement, but now more than ever, being close isn’t good enough; errors cost companies real money, delay shipments, and harm your reputation with Customs. A regular product review isn’t just tedious bookkeeping; it's an active way to avoid major pitfalls and costly delays at Customs. 

With the stakes so high, it just makes sense to lean on an expert. In the same way that you wouldn’t represent yourself in court because you don’t know every relevant legal precedent, attempting to classify your own goods is a surefire way to end up with a hefty audit. A trade lawyer or trade advisor should assist and can even offer processes and tactics to help safeguard your imports, such as an advance ruling. 

With that in mind, never forget that the legal liability of your goods lies with you, and who you hire to manage that is almost as important as the classification itself. 

—

For full assistance with product reviews or anything related to the classification of your goods, either for new imports or to reassess your old databases, you are encouraged to get in touch with our Trade Advisory team today. 

We can help analyze your goods, review your current imports, keep an eye on regulatory changes, and help you routinely reclassify when necessary. 

Most importantly, our team is compliance-first and staffed with industry vets with decades of experience interpreting and working with the HTS. Count on us to help accurately classify your goods now and in the future.

Disclaimer: While reading, kindly note the date of this blog. At PCB we do our due diligence to write on the most relevant topic every week and naturally content may become dated as developments in a certain program/topic occur. For this reason, we greatly appreciate your readership and hope you continue reading with the posting date in mind. For the latest information on this topic please use our website's search function, or better yet, subscribe to our "Trading Post" newsletter to receive these updates directly to your inbox.
Share this post
About the Author
Breanna Leininger
CCS, LCB

Breanna has been in the industry since 2004 and has dealt with clearances and compliance concerns for a multitude of commodities for all ports of entry and all modes of transportation. She has a Bachelors in Communications, Bachelors in Political Science & Government, is a Licensed Customs Broker as well as Certified Customs Specialist. Breanna has been asked to be the speaker in a variety of events including the BC Agriculture Show, Doing Business in the US seminar and has been a contributor to Small Business BC publications. She was recently nominated for the NCBFAA Government Affairs Conference Emerging Leaders and Mentors by the NBCBA. She participates in the Northern Border Customs Brokers Association and the NCBFAA annual conferences in Washington, DC. Breanna has a deep passion for politics, global affairs, and how communication shapes policy and international business relationships. She feels very fortunate to work in an industry that allows her to take part in how policy impacts the global economy and domestic businesses of all shapes and sizes.

Author's Posts

Sign up for The Trading Post Newsletter

Sign up to receive easy to understand updates, events, and guides on international trade.